Home > Uncategorized > The "god is good" oxymoron

The "god is good" oxymoron


Here’s one that REALLY fries me. I have heard and read countless times:

“Life is good” or “god is good.”

These statements are uttered after ritualistic recitals of how someone’s pet cat was saved by a miracle, or some such bullshit.

Really, that’s usually the story, somebody’s fucking pet doesn’t die and bingo, “god is good”.

I can tolerate, and even embrace, statements along the lines of “god has been good to me” or “I am grateful to god.” But I rarely hear or read that.

What I do hear, time and again, are statements equating the goodness and wisdom of some personal deity based on some petty, selfish, MINUSCULE favor bestowed directly on some quivering, two-legged mass of protoplasm, and their saved kitty.

Or how about this one?

“I bought these shoes?

And they didn’t like, fit?

But the next day I walked around in them? And I’m like,

Oh-

My-

God,

They feel so much better today!

God is good”.

I witness this kind of belief system from people with college degrees, jobs, homes, people with arms and legs and heads…people who by any criteria look like ADULTS. Do I live in the same universe as these people? I wonder…

By the time I was seven, I was spending some serious chunks of time wondering why there was so much suffering in the world and what I could do to help change that.

By the time I was 11, I had seen film clips on TV of bulldozer pushing thousands of skeletal human corpses into huge pits.

A disclaimer is in order: as an atheist jew, my thought analogies drift toward “my peoples’” experiences, but I am not, in any way, implying that “our” pain is larger than someone else’s pain. I do not believe that it is. There are six thousand million humans on this planet, and from moment to moment, I would estimate that the majority are living under conditions that might closely resemble, by almost anyone’s criteria, hell.

Or let’s be more specific, on the one hand, we have the god-saved-my-kittten people, on the other hand…

well….go to:

http://www.cbu.edu/~seisen/WhatADrunkDriverCanDo/sld001.htm

My great grandparents escaped the pogroms of Russia.
My grandparents escaped the nazi holocaust.
Question: as a freethinking progressive in the USA, where the fuck am I going to escape to?
Question: once global warming, global dimming, and the die-out of plankton reach critical mass, where will we ALL escape to?

Maybe then, god won’t look so good to anyone but the hare krishnas.

Hannah Arendt posited “the banality of evil”. Imagination and compassion are closely intertwined. Although I am aware of many moving acts of compassion in my own immediate experience (on a daily basis) , as well as from my less immediate experiences, I am still crushed with dismay at the general lack of imagination, by the numbness and paralysis, by the narcissism of my fellow humans.

Is some of what I’m describing a kind of existential “doublethink” (as per Orwell). Time and again, the concept of clinical narcissism comes to mind.

I try to view things as a Taoist. It ain’t easy, but it’s all I got. Being judgmental is stupid. What is, is. But still…I do get pissed off. Mostly though, this shit makes me sad.

Advertisements
Categories: Uncategorized Tags:
  1. Simon
    May 2, 2006 at 8:10 am

    As my friend who is a research scientist (does stuff with lasers or something) “If God did it, then why bother? Why try to find out anything?”

  2. frankpoliat
    May 2, 2006 at 8:15 am

    Hi Simon, you’re my first feedbacker, thank you.

    I guess that’s the nice thing about being an atheist…. I CAN try to find out anything.

  3. Paul Loney
    January 9, 2007 at 2:44 am

    If god is good, then why does god allow our pets to be run over? To teach us? Teach us that teaching only coming through punishment? Tp punish us for “allowing” our pet to be free? etc., etc.

  4. frankpoliat
    January 11, 2007 at 11:47 pm

    Newsflash…there is no Santa Clause, there is no God.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: